This is an AI video generation comparison for
image-to-video 
prompt:
Fat man skates with wild enthusiasm. He twirls, leaps, and slides across the frozen lake in chaotic elegance — the ice groaning dramatically beneath him as shards spray with every spin. His face is locked in fierce concentration, veins bulging, as he attempts a flurry of ballerina pirouettes that verge on both impressive and catastrophic. The camera whips between angles — darting from low gliding shots near his skates to fast, handheld-style closeups of his flushed expression, then swinging wide...
Log in to see full prompt.
Tested: November 10, 2025
Grok takes the gold here, this generation is unparalleled: anatomy, movements, pace and camera work - all excellent
Tested: November 10, 2025
In many cases Kling would make small mistakes when the man is spinning. Overall the generation is fine but not impressive: movements are monotonous and so is the camera movement
Tested: November 10, 2025
Tried to cut down the frantic and chaotic keywords in the prompt as model appears overly sensitive to them, but that didn't help the body warping
Tested: November 10, 2025
This is pretty good. Camera is kind of boring but his movements are accurate and quite dynamic.
Tested: November 10, 2025
It's fine. Camera doesn't go wild though, and the man's movements are rather cautious.
Tested: November 10, 2025
Done 2 tests with this modela and they both were significantly better than Hailuo 2.3 Fast. Movements were different each time but both shown his face up close.
Tested: November 10, 2025
The motion is fine but since it can't do cuts it decides to track the man closely to zoom in on his face & show ' closeups of his flushed expression'.
Tested: November 12, 2025
Crazy skating fat man breaks Pollo 2.0 :) But it's almost there.
Does the fat man skate with visible enthusiasm (twirls, leaps, slides)?
Are the pirouettes and movements both skillful and slightly chaotic, matching the “fever dream” tone?
Does the ice visibly groan or crack under his weight (with synchronized sound or visual cues)?
Do shards of ice spray during spins or landings?
Are there moments where his face is shown in closeup, flushed and strained in concentration?
Does the camera alternate between low angles near his skates, handheld closeups, and wide landscape shots?
Are transitions between camera angles smooth and timed with his movements?
Is snow actively swirling or being disturbed by his motion throughout the scene?
Does the background depict a sweeping, wintry landscape consistent across all angles?
Are lighting and shadows consistent between the low, close, and wide shots?
Does the overall rhythm of motion and editing feel erratic but intentional, enhancing the “fever dream” mood?
Check out the results from GROK (Grok Imagine v0.9) vs Freepik (Kling 2.5 Turbo Standard) vs Freepik (Hailuo 2.3 Fast) vs Freepik (PixVerse V5) vs Fal AI (Seedance 1.0 Pro Fast) vs Freepik (Hailuo 02) vs Wan (Online Platform) (Wan2.5 Preview) vs Pollo AI (Pollo 2.0) for similar or identical prompts side-by-side.
Forest to city whip pan running
Timestamped cat dance sequence
